From the Blog

Brick's Property Taxes Since 2011: What the State's Numbers Show

Barnegat Bay from Camp Osbourne in Brick with the headline about Brick property taxes since 2011 and the Team Brick logo

Part 2 of 4 in Team Brick's series on Brick property taxes since 2011.

Last week we looked at the 2011 referendum that raised Brick's municipal tax rate 24 percent. So what has happened to the bill in the fourteen years since?

Short answer: the township's share has grown slowly. The full bill has grown faster, mostly because of school and county taxes.

All figures below come from the state Division of Local Government Services tax tables, unless we say otherwise. "Average home" means the state's average residential assessment for Brick. Your own bill depends on your own assessment, and fire district taxes are not included.

The average bill, selected years

  • 2011: township levy $67.82M (+23.6%); average township tax $1,931; average total bill $5,907
  • 2012: township levy $67.57M (−0.4%); average township tax $1,928; average total bill $5,946
  • 2013: township levy $64.92M (−3.9%); average township tax $1,849; average total bill $5,880
  • 2018: township levy $72.62M (+3.1%); average township tax $2,072; average total bill $6,488
  • 2020: township levy $76.06M (+3.1%); average township tax $2,175; average total bill $6,819
  • 2023: township levy $80.55M (0.0%); average township tax $2,300; average total bill $7,252
  • 2024: township levy $83.84M (+4.1%); average township tax $2,399; average total bill $7,666
  • 2025: township levy $86.06M (+2.7%); average township tax $2,466; average total bill $8,091

From 2011 to 2025, the average home's township tax went up about $535, or 28 percent. The average total bill went up about $2,183, or 37 percent.

A few years stand out. The first budget under the new Democratic council majority, in 2012, came in slightly lower than 2011, and the 2013 levy dropped almost 4 percent. In 2023, the first budget under Mayor Lisa Crate held the township levy flat. Those are real results, and they belong in any fair account.

Most other years ran between about 1.4 and 4.6 percent, and 2017 dipped slightly. From 2012 through 2023, the township levy grew about 1.5 percent a year on average.

Where the rest of the increase came from

Of that $2,183 increase on the average total bill, about $535 was the township's share. About $1,076 came from school taxes and about $572 from county taxes.

From 2011 to 2025, the township levy grew 26.9 percent. The school levy grew 37.7 percent, and the county levy (including library, health and open space) grew 48.4 percent.

In 2025, schools made up about 47.8 percent of a Brick tax bill before fire district taxes. The township made up 30.9 percent and the county 21.4 percent.

That matters. The township council controls only its own share. A bigger bill reflects three governments at once, plus the fire district.

What the revaluation does to these numbers

Brick reassessed every property in 2010. Assessments more than doubled overnight, and the rates were cut to match. That's why the rates before 2010 can't be compared with the rates after.

Since then, assessments have barely moved, while home prices have. The state's equalization ratio, which compares assessments to market value, fell from about 98 percent in 2014 to about 55 percent in 2025. In plain terms, the average Brick assessment now reflects a little over half of what homes sell for.

One result is easy to miss. Measured against market value, Brick's total tax rate actually fell, from 1.747 percent in 2011 to 1.465 percent in 2025. Bills went up in dollars, but home values went up faster.

The gap between assessments and market value is why the county ordered a new revaluation, which takes effect in 2029. We explained what that means in Brick's Property Revaluation: What the County Ordered, What It Costs, and What Happens Before 2029.

Checking claims made since 2011

Here's how a few recent claims hold up against the state data.

A 2023 Central Jersey News piece said taxes under the Ducey and Crate administrations rose "an average of 1% a year." State data show closer to 1.5 percent a year for the township levy from 2012 through 2023.

The same piece said Mayor Crate's first budget had no municipal tax increase. The 2023 levy was flat, so that holds up.

During the 2025 race, Mayor Crate told Jersey Shore Online: "In the last 12 years under the Ducey and Crate Administrations, municipal taxes have increased only $38 per year." Using the state's average assessment, we got about $41 to $51 a year, depending on which year you start counting from. We don't know what method her campaign used, so we'll just say we couldn't reproduce it from the state data.

2026 so far

The state hasn't published its 2026 tables yet. Brick's 2026 adopted budget summary puts the township levy at $89.92 million, up 4.49 percent. It says the average home's township tax goes from $2,483.10 to $2,592.46, about $109 more. Patch reported the increase at about $98. We're using the township's own figure.

Is this good for the people of Brick?

After 2011, the township's share grew at a modest pace, and in a few years it held flat or dropped. It's also true that the average bill is about $2,200 higher than it was in 2011, and that the 2011 increase is still built into every year since. Next week, in a clearly labeled hypothetical, we'll look at what that has added up to.

Team Brick is a local Republican reform movement in Brick Township, New Jersey. This article reflects the views of Team Brick and was not written or approved by any candidate.

Sources

  1. NJ DCA Division of Local Government Services, Property Tax Information, annual tax tables 2010–2025 (levies, rates, average residential assessment, equalization ratio, equalized rate): https://www.nj.gov/dca/dlgs/resources/Property_Tax_info.shtml
  2. Ocean County Board of Taxation, "2025 Breakdown of General Tax Rate," Sept. 25, 2025 (2025 non-fire components match DLGS): https://www.co.ocean.nj.us/WebContentFiles/db701eb9-d877-4ff6-86d1-d0afe5a792cc.pdf
  3. Brick Township, 2026 Adopted User Friendly Budget (posted Apr. 29, 2026): https://www.bricknj.gov/Documents/Department/Finance/Budgets%20And%20Financial%20Information/2026/2026%20Adopted%20User%20Friendly%20Budget.pdf
  4. Patch, Karen Wall, "Brick Council Approves 2026 Budget With Tax Increase In Split Vote," Apr. 29, 2026: https://patch.com/new-jersey/brick/brick-council-approves-2026-budget-tax-increase-split-vote
  5. Central Jersey News, "Catalano Under Fire for Record on Taxes," Sept. 28, 2023 (unbylined): https://centraljerseynews.com/2023/09/28/catalano-under-fire-for-record-on-taxes/
  6. Jersey Shore Online, Judy Smestad-Nunn, "Mayoral Candidates Face Off In Brick," Oct. 21, 2025: https://www.jerseyshoreonline.com/brick/mayoral-candidates-face-off-in-brick/
  7. Team Brick, "Brick's Property Revaluation: What the County Ordered, What It Costs, and What Happens Before 2029": https://teambrickrepublicans.com/blog/brick-township-property-revaluation-2029-explained/

Header photo: Barnegat Bay from Camp Osbourne, Brick. Photo: Mr. Matté / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Share Facebook X Email

All posts

More from the blog